Market Redesign Competition @ SOCAP/Europe
Start at the bottom to read Kevin Jones’ initial Twitter conversation to kick-off the Market Redesign Competition @ SOCAP/Europe!
@Montero @p2173 canadian bred collab models make sense, agree
@p2173 agree too many vectors for a dominant player needs a network to make sense of this market.
Committed to go to burkina ghana w @RootCapital in march biggest cacao coop, ashante kingdom, shea coops
symbionics making progress on its grand kickstarter plan. i just pledged some more. http://bit.ly/g3AI0P
Kevindoylejones Kevindoylejones
return1st impact investors need a different lens 4 same phenomena/enterprise/fund/project than return1st impact investors#flexibleanalytics
market mapping tools of the market from #impactinvest2philanneed to apply & subtract financial to impact dimensions as needed.
that part is just converting existing market mapping tools over to include the dimesion of impact, per this graphic http://bit.ly/fP2rFX
abstraction layer filters are needed. heat maps do thing geospatial maps don’t do. applying and subtracting issue specific overlays needed
@ayllu your geospatial map is ok. there are also need to be sector, asset class heat maps like map of the markethttp://bit.ly/g21G5s
for enterprises where impact adds value, spreadsheets cells becoming confinement pens, a factory farm tool in a permaculture environment
for money in pursuit of value, a spreadsheet can tell you most of what you need to know.
@rfilsinger giving is where #narrativeaddsvalue, and#leftbrainanalytic adds validation. get em wrong, #fail
@rfilsinger but nobody reported on why seachange failed. they thought people giving was left brain analytic function,#spreadsheetaddsvalue
@rfilsinger one of the foundations, hewlett i think, held roundtable, kellog did a paper, as i recall. major funder asked a limited question
@Montero is it a #charitybizpbj or a legit partnership is a#thriveabilitymetric element, dont’ u think, @nurturegirl ?
@Montero yeah it’s beneficaries and recipients and it’s also becoming indigenous capital as a new,stronger player
@rfilsinger jim mcclurg knows the seachange story best, former SEA staffer, now a minister, long time #socent before that
@slboval not sure who the best #sensemakeplayers are yet. i think it’s a segment that will evolve quickly as new money comes into the market
@Montero i am seeing much higher quality of #socententrepreneurs coming into the field, areas like #offgridpowergen in bay area.
@conches @p2173 they play the gartner role. independent analysis
@rfilsinger did it somewhere, a long time ago, when i was on the SEA board, & we merged w seachange remains Fruchterman was deeeply involved
@slboval @Montero making sense of the market from impact investing to philanthropy @p2173
@rfilsinger foundations have myopic focuses, narrow theories of change, that’s the ugliest sludge in market from#impactinvest2philan,
@rfilsinger the private capital market has enrons; companies that fail spectacularly pursuing a grand vision that gets corrupted.
@rfilsinger lack of accountability by foundations for their actions is biggest structural piece of stupidity in mkt @p2173 &I I talk about
@rfilsinger but the worst is that foundation theories of change are not tested for their unintended externalities & consequences
@rfilsinger the fact that foundations are not held to account for their relative success or failure on their theory of change is oe thing.
@rfilsinger the fact that foundations don’t have to get actually smart is probably the biggest stupid thing i see all the time.
@rfilsinger what was worse, though was that they only reported on how seachange did not meet the #theoryofchange of the largest foundation
@rfilsinger the first version of seachange, the $4m funded online philanthropic market is one of the dumbest things i’ve seen in a decade.
@Montero agree montero. can you make that into a#thriveabilitymetric element,
@ogunte want to help design a better capital market? one where we all win, but there can also be winners? @socapeurope
@shrock @PYMWYMIC @SoCapEurope @ogunte glad 2 meet you we’re doing a #marketdesign competion for @socapeuropedesign one where we all win
ok, the market @p2173 & I are talking about being#sensemakerplayers 4 is from impact investing to philanthropy. defining that market
that is exactly what i mean @p2173: do you mean the range from giving 2 impactinvesting is market we’re discussing? if so, yes, I abs agree
#sensemakerplayers by the rules as expressed so far, work collectively, as various units of collective intelligence @slboval
@slboval @montero you first, Sam on defining#senesmakerplayers what does it mean to you when you see it? what does it not mean?
@p2173 the asset class fan is from impact investing to philaanthropy? that’s the market segment we r talking about., right? a question 2 you
designcompetitions have an inherent projectrunway element. some designs are better and their value should be made clear
the #marketdesign competition will try not 2 make people look stupid just to prove a point @socapeurope but only a few make it 2 bryant park
the people in #socent doing dumb things are mostly pushed there by power & money relationships that have more structural, systemic power
@Montero well putting lipstick on a pig is a key to getting funding, in this world. that just shows the distortion of the market intruding
Kevindoylejones Kevindoylejones
how much #boringnoise does your market design have? that gets you point off in my book, anyway.
how are the barbarians welcomed, a key design spec that #socent#fails on. 2 many walled gardens, 2 many exclusive arbiters.#boringnoise
problem is silos themselves kneejerk design spec . getting just right people in the room is a #fail, @montero#marketsmakeroom4barbarians
@Montero #silofrictionbarriers is a key thing to design to solve for in the #marketdesign competition at @socapeurope key markret barrier
@Montero yeah none of the #sensemakerplayers are good enough yet, and the lack of quality, friction is slowing #socentdown
@SOCAPmarkets there’s a great permaculture design school a block from hub berkeley, @sourceforge is east bay
@SOCAPmarkets scharfenberger, senda athletics ceo, yoni & cofed all engage young people & the world well. east bay ashoka youth, too
#thrivabilitymetrics & others need 2 measure what matters, not what u can count, or force someone else to count @socapeuropedesign comp
profit metrics have to cut costs &or increase margin, but value for all is a key component of the #thriveabilitymetric
#topiconvogame ability. a quality to have if you want to be a#sensemakerplayer a profit metric
when assessing social media potency & collective intelligence value, ability to create & consecutively cocreate a #topiconvogamea metric
What is the neuron speed of a great, short current in a twitter stream? collective handoffs within a network is a new kind of#topiconvogame
Will the #sensemakerplayers put their money where their mouth is? @pymwymic a key design criteria. walking the talk,#thriveabilitymetric
All the #sensemakerplayers are saying collab is the key. now let’s all see how we do at living up to that, in the daylight. @socapeurope
@p2173 @allyu glad you see partnership by #sensemakerplayersto be essential, Lucy. & what about mkt from#impactinvesttophilanas spread?
I’m calling #gameon for #sensemakerplayers for @socapeuropemultiple winners, no one loses. Redesigned Chutes & Ladders, a win win game
The parties who want to be #sensemakingplayers in the @socapeurope #marketdesign competition should help design the judging, i think.
of course, that’s just my take on the riffs that just went down @socapeurope design competition has 2 factor in everybody’s falibilit
@socapeurope‘s capital market, #impactinvesttophilan design competition was great fun. Thanks, everybody for playing.
Claiming positions in a glimmer in the eye sector of a not quite clear asset class before lunch, got love @socapeurope design competition
#Venicethriveabilitymetric wealth & power displayed thru a strong commons by #collectiveinteligence the #sensemakerplayer
#walledgardens4therich is #fail in the #impactinvest #newphilansocialcapital market. a strong commons is where wealth is displayed. Venice
the social capital market flows both ways; value from there, 2 here, not just the west & its beneficiaries. #countryclub #philan is a #fail
#sensemakers who work behind closed doors, with just the right people in the room, w not prevail in #socent power dynamics are all wrong
Amazing what lurking interest there was in the #sensemakerspace, and now how many moves have been made out in the open.
@benmetz a blog that covered the #sensemaker beat would be a blog I would read and help contribute to. group blogs might be the way to go?
@benmetz i think that’s my only criteria for blogs these days; more reporting less abstract discussions. even reporting on thinkers maybe
@benmetz so are we supposed to be paying more attention to your blog, Ben? how often will you write, will u talk about others a lot?
multiple players seeking the top spot can still work as they eliminate friction and increase productivity
@ayllu @p2173 the market we are engaged in, the three of us, is#sensemaker space. it will become more valuable turf, partnerships prevail
@ayllu ayllu, I like your ambition, claiming a top position is good ground 2 claim as #socent becomes a real market.#sensemakerspace
@ayllu @p2173 id love to talk. will be doing the listening tour for @socapeurope during that time, but could call in
The synchronicity of keeping the Collective Intelligence domain two days ago is kind of odd. solctice, eclipse, full moon kind of odd
Collective Intelligence is the best name for a smartmob, crowdsourced version of a Gartner like sense making intermediary in #socent
I’m glad i kept the collective intelligence url http://bit.ly/9fON9r this week. that bill almost slipped through the email ether.
@peoplecentred @benmetz Kim Alter was one of my first teachers in #socent i learned a lot from her approach.
market is a game. smart alphas win. winning needs 2 help others#thriveabilitymetric it’s not just a place 2 play nice, or hide yer ambition
wealth and power can show off for the good of the whole.#thriveabilitymetric element.
Venice : wealth showed itself by building a greater cultural commons. historic #thriveabilitymetric element. how does wealth show off?
Venice at its’ height; strongest, smartest man showed it by how he gave back to his community in substantial public infrastructure.
#thriveabilitymetric appropriate vehicles for male ego, need 2 shine, eg. venice where wealth showed by giving 2 public institutions.
#thriveability will still reward those who do best, they w profit but the whole will profit by winners profiting most. a rotarian universe
#thriveabilitymetric you still have winners, players who get to the highest, mitochondria-like positions in the market.win41 = win 4 all
#thriveabilitymetric includes a well managed commons, with individual effort being rewarded within the context of the good of the whole.
#thriveabilitymetric is something @nurturegirl can explain. it’s her new product line for thriveability. it’s the high ground we all like
@ayllu @benmetz yeah ayllu, i agree w @p2173 it probably needs to start out like a crowded space, to build highest#thriveabilitymetric
we are having a market design competition at @socapeurope. who can design the best market where we could all thrive.#thriveabilitymetric
@p2173 @p2173 @benmetz markets have shapes. in redesigning a philantoimpactinvest market you need to build visual models @socapeurope
@p2173 @benmetz usually in spaces like that there is not a bell curve; it’s more of a power law. google, eg. votex of growing market shape
@SchSocEnt yeah have heard about pinboard. i like modest ambitions on their about space. that’s the way to build today; network transparent
@benmetz somebody needs to build the Gartner of the #socentspace. a trusted analytic intermediary, the sense maker. 4 due diligence
@benmetz definitions r at the core of an analyst business. & today u network the experts, u don’t warehouse them #socent screaming biz
@benmetz maybe what this #socent market needs is a crowdsourced version of Gartner; the trusted third party, definer, analyst, trend tracker
@benmetz the quality of sense making intermediaries is a real lagging point in this market. biggest opp is collective trust builder.#socent
@peoplecentred @benmetz yeah getting clear on definitions matters cuz there is new $, human capital in the room looking 2 get smart quick
@benmetz cool dude, will check out yer definition. they can be crazy foxholes, but there is demand for clear definitions w new $ in room
@SEIreland do you want to do #crowdsourced philanthropy in Ireland for social enterprise?
Come help us redesign the capital market into something we can all live with. play for real. @socapeurope. http://linkd.in/ghJm2P